Does this work???

I cant decide if I like this or not? What do you guys think? Please tell me your honest opinion- you will not hurt my feelings at all.
I am normally not a huge fan of the black and white pictures with one thing colored- but when Elise showed up in this fabulous red dress- I thought to myself- hmmmm this could work.

Please let me know what you guys think- I am in desperate need of some advice- on this one

Note: you can see the full color version of this photo a couple of posts down....